Homemade Fudge Buy 1 lb Get 1/2 lb FREE! Fudge Sampler

  • $29.95
    Unit price per 
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Homemade fudge made fresh everyday.  Get 1 1/2 lbs for the price of 1lb!  25 flavors to choose from with the addition of seasonal rotating flavors.

Can't decide? Then this is the box for you. Create your own assortment and mix and match up to 3 flavors cut in 1/2 lb pieces. Each 1/2 lb piece comes individually wrapped with the flavor labeled. Keep some for yourself, give one to a friend. 

Available flavors: (Choose 3 Flavors)
Amaretto Chocolate - A layer of Amaretto Fudge swirled with a layer Chocolate Fudge

Chocolate - Classic smooth and creamy chocolate fudge

Chocolate Walnut - Our original chocolate fudge loaded with walnuts

Cookies 'N Cream - Vanilla fudge mixed with chunks of creme-filled chocolate cookies

Creme Brulee - A modern take on a traditional classic, crispy caramelized sugar topping and all. 

Dark Chocolate - Our original chocolate fudge intensified with a deeper, more intense chocolate flavor.

Dark Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt - Dark chocolate fudge layered with caramel and topped with sea salt

Salted Caramel - Vanilla fudge delicately blended with ribbons of salted caramel and topped with coarse sea salt

Mint Chocolate Swirl -  A layer of our original chocolate fudge swirled with scrumptious green-colored mint fudge

Heath English Toffee - Vanilla fudge blended with Heath® English Toffee Chunks

Orange Cream - Orange and vanilla combination, tastes just like one of those Ice cream treats we all love


Penuche Praline - Tasty pecans and caramel nestled between two layers of Penuche Fudge, a creamy sensation with the full-bodied flavor of brown sugar.

Peanut Butter - Vanilla Fudge mixed with Jif® Creamy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter Chocolate - A layer of mouthwatering peanut butter fudge and a layer of our original chocolate fudge

Rocky Road - Chocolate fudge mixed with mini marshmallows and walnuts

Chewy Praline - Vanilla fudge layered with a slab of caramel and pecans

Vanilla Bean - Classic smooth and creamy vanilla fudge

Red Velvet - Dramatic layers of red velvet and cream cheese flavored fudge make this an elegant and decadent treat (WE WON 1ST PLACE AT THE UTAH STATE FAIR WITH THIS ONE)

Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle - Layers of dark chocolate fudge and raspberry fudge topped with a decorative drizzle

Maple - Vanilla fudge mixed with maple flavoring

Tiger Butter - Smooth vanilla fudge layered with real peanut butter and drizzled with classic chocolate fudge

Turtle - classic chocolate kicked up a notch with loads of caramel and pecans

Birthday Cake - Vanilla fudge blended with just the right amount birthday cake flavor and sprinkles

Milk Chocolate - Just plain 'ol creamy, delicious Milk Chocolate Fudge

Seasonal Flavors:

Orders ship within 2-3 business days USPS priority mail. We would be happy to ship a gift for you to another address. Please include name and address when ordering.


Allergen Information contains: soy, milk and has been made in a facility that processes soy, milk, wheat, egg, peanuts, tree nuts and coconut.

Customer Reviews

Based on 82 reviews
Lisa M

This is some of the very best fudge I have ever had, moist and delicious! Keep doing what you are doing. I will order again soon. Thank you.

Cynthia Brown
Just wasn’t my version of fudge

I’m used to homemade fudge being firmer and not as gooey. I was not overly impressed. I won’t be ordering again. I have only had one small bite of each flavor to try them. Not gonna lie. I have no problem not eating it.

Thank you for your feedback. We ship our fudge super fresh which is the reason for it's soft consistency. If you like a firmer fudge, you can just leave it sit at room temperature for several weeks (yes, we did say weeks because that is how fresh our fudge is when we ship it out) and you'll end up with a harder, more firm fudge which may be much more to your liking. It can also be refrigerated if you prefer your fudge with a harder consistency.

Ana Howerton
Order in advance during holidays

It took 3 weeks for my order to arrive. I placed my order on Dec 14 and arrived here on Jan 6. Be sure to order in advance during the holidays.

Thank you for the feedback. Any yes, we do encourage everyone to order early around any holiday, especially Christmas, as our volume increases tremendously. Most years, orders placed after December 10 can expect a 1-2 week processing time before we ship the order.


Bought it for a Christmas gift and they absolutely loved it. Chocolate, Salted Caramel and Maple were all delicious!

Tami McLeod
Order not received

Unfortunately, the order placed two weeks ago was never received. Will revise review if it is received.

We apologize for the UPS delay. The order was placed on 12/21 at 5:22 pm and shipped on 12/22/21 at 10:43 am. UPS has shown several severe weather delays on your item and is currently trying to deliver.